I Got a Rejection Letter.
Ed. note: Welcome to the latest installment of
“Janet Raiffa’s Recessionals,” a column by a laid-off recruiting manager in New York. Prior columns are collected [here]. You can reach Janet Raiffa via LinkedIn, leaving a comment here, or emailing 405club@gmail.com.
Last week I got a rejection letter. Rejection is nothing unusual to me these days. In fact, you can say that it has become my new middle name. I now consider myself lucky that my old middle name was Robin so I don’t have to worry about changing my monogram. This letter was unusual only because snail mail rejections are increasingly uncommon; in most other cases I’ve received the news via email, or in more than a few cases have simply never heard from an employer or a headhunter again. The other things that were notable about this rejection were that it was from a university I’d hired from successfully for years as a representative of one of its most wildly desired employers, and that the job would have required me to take a $120K+ plus pay decrease from what I earned in my last two jobs.
Receiving the letter didn’t surprise or hurt too much because it was weeks after the first round phone interview – perhaps the most rigorous and unpleasant phone interview I’d ever had - and I’d already drawn the conclusion that the response wasn’t positive. In fact, the thin envelope made me faintly nostalgic for my senior year in college. That was way back before email correspondence was the norm and seniors proudly displayed their rejection letters on the doors of their dormitory rooms, or papered their walls with them. They were called “ding” letters on my campus, and I remember that receiving them then was somewhat more humorous than I’m finding it now. I briefly wondered whether it would be appropriate if I mounted it on my apartment door, if only to put off the well meaning neighbor across the hall. He persists in asking me if anything is happening on the job front every single time he sees me.
This return to the reality of unemployment came after one of the best months I have had since my layoff…


In a few months, the effort paid off. I can now fit into almost every size 8 GAP has to sell – a size I hadn’t bought since high school in the 80s – and in one or two particularly generous cuts I can fit into a 6 without major damage to my circulatory system. I was never truly obese, and am well aware that the average American woman wears a size 14, but the improvements to my health and fitness levels have been truly amazing. My heart rate while resting and working out decreased so much that I had to switch machines several times to prove that there wasn’t a mechanical problem, and I can now push myself harder and get to levels that increase my weight loss and cardiovascular efforts. I used to be plagued by exercise induced asthma that necessitated frequent inhaler usage when I wound down from a workout in the locker room, and now that’s stopped. I won’t get into the embarrassing chafing that afflicts women who have too much of a good thing, but as a 36D I now suffer from very little of what I did sporting a 40 inch bra.
executive with a recruiting focus during a recession and a single woman of a certain age in New York has given me a tolerance for rejection so high that very few 20-somethings are able to compete. When I was called for one last tour of duty to advocate before the election began I couldn’t turn down the chance to both wrap up the campaign process and earn $70 for early morning and late afternoon/evening shift that would leave most of my day free for other activities. I also felt much better about the job since The New York Times published an article about the laid off lawyers and bankers joining campaigns as volunteers or low paid workers. One of the featured campaigners was a former Goldman Sachs analyst, someone I could have easily hired a few years ago at the firm, who described bumping into still employed old banking colleagues while passing out flyers on the street.
excited about my Law and Order debut the next morning. After registering with Central Casting in June, I’d been submitting for multiple listings weekly, but never heard anything even when the need seemed to be frantic and openings were broadcast several times in a day. I couldn’t stretch myself into many of the “breakdowns” I received each day via email, like the postings that called for “Asian gangster types,” “real nurses” “fashion model types“ and “men with NYPD uniforms,” but there were always generic roles for background actors of “all ethnicities” from “18-101” and professional categories that I could reasonably fit into. Most of the listings came with instructions not to call, but when a Law and Order posting appeared with directions to phone the hotline I dialed immediately. It took me six times to get through, and then I was placed on hold so long that it was almost like trying to reach Time Warner regarding cable service, but I finally got an actual human who looked up my hideous picture and told me that I was confirmed as an “angry computer nerd” with several costume changes. I was instructed to bring two business suits in muted colors and a more casual look, assigned the number 33, and told to call a hotline that night to confirm my call time for the Chelsea Piers shoot. I felt a tremendous nostalgia for my old world of business trips as I packed my travel bag that night, and as I rifled through my fall suits I imagined that t my old cotton friends from Ann Taylor were elated about being dusted off and pressed after months of inactivity.
I quickly discovered that none of the spaces I was directed to was going to be large enough; the image of George Clooney at the airport was 15 feet long, and would not fit even if it were suspended from the ceiling. The manager radioed a maintenance guy to assist me, and after almost giving up on ways to mount George, he told me that the best idea would be to suspend the banner from the railing above an escalator bank on the uppermost theater floor. As a novice banner installer, I had to let him do most of the work of threading the wiring through the banner and affixing it to the railing while I held on for dear life. I was convinced that I was going to fall over the railing because it was so heavy, killing myself for the promise of $15, or that the banner would fall down and take out a customer traveling up on the escalator. Then again, if I were going to be injured by having something fall on top of me, George Clooney would be pretty high on the list of desirable tumblers.